Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Lyudmil Simeonov ( lyudmilsimeonov@yahoo.com ) Corresponding author: Elena Ivanova ( elena.ivanova.leny@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Tsvetomir Loukanov
© 2025 Lyudmil Simeonov, Dimitar Pechilkov, Elena Ivanova, Anna Kaneva-Nencheva.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Simeonov L, Pechilkov D, Ivanova E, Kaneva-Nencheva A (2025) Exercise performance in fontan patients – a single-center Bulgarian study. Bulgarian Society of Medical Sciences Journal 7: e168566. https://doi.org/10.3897/bsms.7.168566
|
Aim: Exercise capacity in Fontan patients is reduced compared to healthy peers and progressive decline in cardiovascular function is expected over time. The purpose of this study is to present, analyze and discuss the initial Bulgarian experience with exercise performance of Fontan patients and to compare them to age-matched healthy peers. Additionally, we focused on understanding whether peak oxygen consumption can be predicted based on multiple independent variables.
Materials and methods: The research is a retrospective observational study of 11 patients aged 8y-18y, who had undergone the Fontan procedure and underwent cardiopulmonary exercise testing in National Heart Hospital in Sofia, Bulgaria. Data were collected for a 1-year period. Simultaneously, 11 age-matched healthy patients were selected for comparison.
Results: Patients with Fontan palliation had lower peak oxygen consumption (23.1 ml/kg/min vs. 30.1 ml/kg/min, P=0.046), percent-predicted peak oxygen consumption (52% vs. 76%, P<0. 001), percent-predicted peak work (56% vs. 82%, P<0.001), percent-predicted peak oxygen consumption at ventilatory anaerobic threshold (37% vs. 48%, P=0.04), resting saturation (93% vs. 97%, P<0.001) and saturation at peak work (84% vs. 95%, P<0.001). Male subjects and patients with left ventricular dominance exhibited a greater peak oxygen consumption.
Conclusion: Exercise capacity in the Bulgarian Fontan cohort is reduced relative to healthy controls. Male gender and subjects with left ventricular dominance have a greater peak oxygen consumption.
Cardiopulmonary exercise testing, exercise performance, fontan procedure
The Fontan operation is the last of series of operations for a group of congenital cardiovascular anomalies in which it is not possible to maintain two-ventricle physiology [
Deterioration of cardiovascular efficiency leads to reduced exercise capacity. Contributing factors to exercise impairment include failure to increase stroke volume, chronotropic incompetence and reduced arterial blood saturation. Cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPET) has an important role in the management of patients after Fontan operation. Peak oxygen uptake (peak VO2) is a significant index of exercise capacity and has a prognostic value in patients with congenital heart disease [
The purpose of this study was to present the initial Bulgarian experience with exercise performance of Fontan patients and compare them to their healthy peers. This paper also focuses on understanding whether peak VO2 can be predicted based on multiple independent variables.
A retrospective observational study was conducted in Fontan patients referred to the Pediatric Cardiology Department in National Heart Hospital in Sofia, Bulgaria. This is the only center in the country involved in the surgical treatment of congenital heart defects. Patients aged 8y-18y with functionally univentricular heart who had undergone the Fontan procedure and had CPET were investigated. Exclusion criteria from the study were patients less than 8 or above 18 years of age and a submaximal effort test. Data were collected over a one-year period, from August 2021 to August 2022, involving the patients that met the inclusion criteria (11 out of 19 patients). Simultaneously, 11 age-matched healthy patients from outpatient visits were selected for comparison. Additional factors assessed included ventricular morphology (right, left), ventricular dysfunction and more than moderate atrioventricular valve regurgitation, evaluated by echocardiography. The Ethics Committee in our institution approved the study protocol and waived the need for patient consent due to the study’s retrospective nature.
The authors reviewed patients’ medical files for baseline characteristics and anatomic details. We defined the primary outcome of interest: peak VO2, a direct measurement of cardiorespiratory fitness [
Transthoracic echocardiography was performed using Philips Epic 7c ultrasound system with X5-1 transducer. We graded atrioventricular valve regurgitation (AVVR) according to the American Society of Echocardiography recommended criteria: none to trivial, 0; mild, 1; mild to moderate, 2; moderate to severe, 3; and severe, 4 [
All patients underwent CPET on an electrically braked cycle ergometer (Lode Corival; Lode BV, Groningen, The Netherlands). Meanwhile, VO2 was measured using a commercial, breath-by-breath gas analysis system (Ultima-CPX, MGC Diagnostics Corp., St. Paul, Minnesota). A RAMP protocol was used, in which the patient should maintain a pedaling speed of about 60/minute. After an initial warm-up period of 2–3 minutes, the pedal resistance is gradually increased at a rate, based on the patient’s age, weight, gender, and level of fitness so that they reach peak exertion in 8–12 minutes. Anaerobic threshold was calculated using the V-slope method (170029). Oxygen pulse - a surrogate for stroke volume - was measured by dividing absolute oxygen uptake by heart rate. Also, VE/VCO2 slope was assessed at VAT. Blood pressure was measured every 2 minutes with an automatic cuff and a 12-lead ECG was obtained throughout the whole exercise. A maximal effort test was defined as peak respiratory exchange ratio (RER)³ 1.05.
The authors used descriptive statistics to provide frequencies and percentages for categorical variables and medians, and interquartile ranges for continuous variables. We used the students t-test to compare variables between Fontan patients and healthy patients. Normality was checked based on the normal Q-Q plot and histogram. Gender, age at Fontan, age at CPET, ventricular dominance, pulmonary vasodilator therapy, more than moderate AVVR and ventricular dysfunction were assessed for linearity with peak VO2. Out of the 7 independent variables only gender and ventricular dominance were significantly linearly related. A multiple regression was run to predict peak VO2 from gender and ventricular dominance. A value of P£0.05 indicated statistical significance. We used IBM SPSS Statistics 24 (IBM Corp., Armonk, N.Y., USA) for statistical analysis.
We had 19 Fontan patients who were referred to the Pediatric Cardiology Department in National Heart Hospital in Sofia, Bulgaria between August, 2021 and August, 2022. A total of 11 patients were included in the study, regarding the including criteria. Fontan patients’ characteristics are summarized in Table
It is accurate to note that Only 1 patient (9.1%) had more than moderate AVVR and none of the observed patients had neither moderate, nor severe ventricular dysfunction and this may explain the fairly preserved numbers compared to larger registries. Hereby, we should mention that low burden of ventricular dysfunction in this group might bias results toward better exercise outcomes.
All of the single ventricle patients had an extracardiac Fontan procedure. Comparison between Fontan patients and healthy subjects is presented in Table
| Variable | Fontan (N=11) |
|---|---|
| Male (n, %) | 9 (82%) |
| Body mass index (BMI), median (range) | 19.8 (15.1–22.6) |
| Age at CPET (years), median (range) | 17 (11–17.9) |
| Diagnosis (n, %): | |
| • Tricuspid atresia | 2 (18.2%) |
| • Pulmonary atresia/intact ventricular septum | 3 (27.3%) |
| • Double outlet right ventricle | 1 (9.1%) |
| • Complex transposition of the great arteries | 2 (18.2%) |
| • Double inlet left ventricle | 3 (27.3%) |
| Dominant left ventricle (n, %) | 7 (63.6%) |
| More than moderate AVVR (n, %) | 1 (9.1%) |
| Ventricular dysfunction (n, %) | |
| • Mild | 4 (36.4%) |
| • Moderate | 0 |
| • Severe | 0 |
| Age at Fontan completion (years), median (range) | 3.3 (2.9–4.8) |
| Conduit size (n, %): | |
| • 16 mm | 3 (37.3%) |
| • 18 mm | 6 (54.5%) |
| • 19 mm | 1 (9.1%) |
| • 20 mm | 1 (9.1%) |
| Fenestration (n, %) | 3 (27.3%) |
| Pulmonary vasodilator (n, %) | 4 (36.4%) |
| Variable | Healthy patients (N = 11) | Fontan patients (N = 11) | P |
|---|---|---|---|
| Male (%) | 7 (63.6) | 9 (82) | 0.35 |
| Body mass index (BMI), median (range) | 19.3 (14.7–22.9) | 19.8 (15.1–22.6) | 0.89 |
| Age at CPET (years), median (range) | 14.1 (9.4–17.2) | 17 (11–17.9) | 0.13 |
All of the study subjects achieved maximal effort test. Exercise capacity in our Fontan cohort was reduced compared to healthy peers - patients after Fontan palliation had lower peak VO2 (23.1 ml/kg/min vs. 30.1 ml/kg/min, P=0.046), percent-predicted peak VO2 (52% vs. 76%, P<0.001), percent-predicted peak work (56% vs. 82%, P<0.001), percent-predicted peak VO2 at VAT (37% vs. 48%, P=0.04), resting saturation (93% vs. 97%, P<0.001) and saturation at peak work (84% vs. 95%, P<0.001). None of the patients exhibited ECG abnormalities and one Fontan patients had an abnormal blood pressure response. Comparison of CPET parameters between the two groups is demonstrated in Table
| Variables | Healthy patients (N = 11) | Fontan patients (N = 11) | P | Mean difference | 95% CI | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LL | UL | |||||
| Ramp protocol (W), median (range) | 15 (10–20) | 15 (10–20) | 0.71 | 0.45 | -2.326 | 3.235 |
| Peak work (W), median (range) | 126 (77–186) | 125 (45–189) | 0.51 | 18.20 | -16.35 | 52.71 |
| Percent-predicted peak work (%), median (range) | 82 (60–100) | 56 (27–75) | <0.001 | 23.73 | 11.632 | 35.822 |
| Peak oxygen consumption (ml/kg/min), median (range) | 30.1 (19.4–42.3) | 23.1 (15.2–40.3) | 0.046 | 5.73 | -0.589 | 12.043 |
| Percent-predicted peak oxygen consumption (%), median (range) | 76 (65–100) | 52 (31–91) | <0.001 | 27.20 | 13.690 | 40.672 |
| Peak RER, median (range) | 1.16 (1.05–1.51) | 1.24 (1.06–1.30) | 0.53 | -0.12 | -0.103 | 0.101 |
| Peak oxygen pulse (%), median (range) | 86 (48–98) | 63 (53–108) | 0.21 | 7.73 | -8.328 | 23.783 |
| Peak heart rate (bpm), median (range) | 176 (149–195) | 162 (103–196) | 0.09 | 16.10 | -2.625 | 34.807 |
| Percent-predicted peak heart rate (%), median (range) | 84 (71–96) | 80 (49–96) | 0.12 | 7.10 | -2.456 | 16.638 |
| Percent-predicted peak oxygen consumption at VAT (%), median (range) | 48 (28–65) | 37 (25–60) | 0.04 | 10.23 | 0.385 | 20.069 |
| VE/VCO2 at VAT, median (range) | 28 (25–31) | 32 (21–41) | 0.14 | -3.10 | -7.083 | 0.901 |
| Resting saturation (%), median (range) | 97 (96–99) | 93 (78–96) | <0.0001 | 6.45 | 2.800 | 10.108 |
| Saturation at peak exercise (%), median (range) | 95 (93–98) | 84 (70–94) | <0.0001 | 10 | 5.433 | 14.566 |
| ECG abnormalities | 0 | 0 | 0.98 | 0 | -0.872 | 0.145 |
| Abnormal blood pressure response | 0 | 1 | 0.32 | 0 | -0.090 | 0.281 |
A multiple regression was run to predict peak VO2 from gender and ventricular dominance. The multiple regression model statistically significantly predicted peak VO2, F (2, 8) = 12.998, P = 0.003, adj. R2= .71. Both gender and ventricular dominance added statistically significantly to the prediction, P=0.003. Male Fontan patients exhibited higher peak VO2 of 11.925 ml/kg/min. Peak VO2 for patients with left ventricular dominance was 7.738 ml/kg/min, greater than patients with right ventricular dominance. Regression coefficients and standard errors can be found in Table
Patients with functionally univentricular heart survive satisfactory into adulthood after Fontan completion [
Cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPET) is a crucial tool to objectively assess exercise performance and functional capacity in patients with congenital heart disease. Access to CPET in Bulgaria is not routine and scarce experience has been gained in recent years. This method provides objective data for assessing functional limitations, tracking disease progression, and guiding personalized treatment strategies. By monitoring objective metrics over time, CPET helps tailor exercise prescriptions, optimize timing for interventions, identify early signs of complications, and guides the creation of personalized, safe exercise programs to improve long-term outcomes.
This study documents that in practice, exercise capacity in Bulgarian Fontan patients is reduced compared to healthy peers. The performed multiple regression analysis reveals that male patients and patients with left ventricular dominance have a greater peak VO2.
We demonstrated that peak VO2, as well as VO2 at VAT and percent-predicted peak work vary significantly between Fontan patients and healthy subjects. These finding extend those of others [
In accordance with previous findings [
There are limited data on patients with Fontan physiology regarding exercise parameter difference between males and females. Seckeler and colleagues previously reported that peak VO2 decreased by 32% through adolescence in females and did not have the typical increase for adolescence for males [
Some limitations are worth noting. A RAMP protocol was used via cycle ergometer, which means that obtained peak VO2 is lower than uphill treadmill running. Cycle ergometry was used mainly because of the relatively young patients age. Another limitation is the single-center, retrospective, non-randomized design of the study. Also, the small sample size in this research may limit the ability to observe significant differences.
Cardiopulmonary exercise testing has an important role in management of patients after Fontan operation. Our current data on the topic provide the first description of exercise capacity in Bulgarian Fontan patients. Our initial experience revealed that patients after the Fontan procedure have impaired exercise performance compared to healthy peers. Male gender and left ventricular dominance are associated with greater peak VO2. These findings address the need for serial cardiopulmonary exercise testing in Fontan patients to monitor for declining peak oxygen consumption. Future multicenter collaborations with larger Fontan cohorts are needed for better understanding exercise capacity trajectories and identifing factors associated with outcomes over time.
Conflict of interest
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Ethical statements
The authors declared that no clinical trials were used in the present study.
The authors declared that no experiments on humans or human tissues were performed for the present study.
The authors declared that no informed consent was obtained from the humans, donors or donors’ representatives participating in the study.
The authors declared that no experiments on animals were performed for the present study.
The authors declared that no commercially available immortalised human and animal cell lines were used in the present study.
Use of AI
No use of AI was reported.
Funding
No funding was reported.
Author contributions
All authors have contributed equally.
Author ORCIDs
Lyudmil Simeonov  https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1853-9739
Dimitar Pechilkov  https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9734-0479
Anna Kaneva-Nencheva  https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7902-5494
Data availability
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text or Supplementary Information.